Exceptionally Monadic Error Handling

by Jan Malakhovski, published

A paper giving a long overview of all existing mechanisms used by various programming languages for error handling (which is a useful thing by itself) and then formally showing that the conventional try-catch can be implemented in terms of a Monad indexed on the computation's error type..

Abstract

We notice that the type of catch :: c a -> (e -> c a) -> c a operator is a special case of monadic bind operator (>>=) :: m a -> (a -> m b) -> m b, the semantics (surprisingly) matches, and this observation has many interesting consequences.

For instance, the reader is probably aware that the monadic essence of the (>>=) operator of the error monad λA.EA\lambda A.E \lor A is to behave like identity monad for “normal” values and to stop on “errors”. The unappreciated fact is that handling of said “errors” with a catch operator of the “flipped” “conjoined” error monad λE.EA\lambda E.E \lor A is, too, a monadic computation that treats still unhandled “errors” as “normal” values and stops when an “error” is finally handled.

We show that for an appropriately indexed type of computations such a “conjoined” structure naturally follows from the conventional operational semantics of throw and catch operators. Consequently, we show that this structure uniformly generalizes all conventional monadic error handling mechanisms we are aware of. We also demonstrate several more interesting instances of this structure of which at least bi-indexed monadic parser combinators and conventional exceptions implemented via continuations have immediate practical applications. Finally, we notice that these observations provide surprising perspectives on error handling in general and point to a largely unexplored trail in programming language design space.

Changelog

Downloads:

See also